The Sunnah as Determinative over the Qur’ān: An Evaluation of Sūrah al-Nisā 4:34
RELIGIONS, vol.17, no.1258, pp.1-16, 2026 (AHCI, Scopus)
- Publication Type: Article / Article
- Volume: 17 Issue: 1258
- Publication Date: 2026
- Doi Number: 10.3390/rel17111258
- Journal Name: RELIGIONS
- Journal Indexes: Academic Search Ultimate (EBSCO), Scopus, Religion Database (ProQuest), Arts and Humanities Citation Index (AHCI), ATLA Religion Database, Index Islamicus, Linguistic Bibliography, Directory of Open Access Journals
- Page Numbers: pp.1-16
- Open Archive Collection: AVESIS Open Access Collection
- Akdeniz University Affiliated: Yes
Abstract
This study aims to examine the decisive role of the Sunnah in the practical interpretation of Qur’ānic verses through the principle of “al‑Sunnah qāḍiyatun ʿalā al‑Kitāb” (the Sunnah is determinative with respect to the Qur’ān), a principle that has formed the basis of profounddiscussionswithintheIslamicmethodologicaltradition,withparticularfocuson Qur’ān4:34. Theresearcharguesthattheactof“strikingawoman”(darb)mentionedinthe verse is directly connected to the socio‑cultural context of the revelationperiod. Withinthis framework, it is maintained that the verse should be understood not as a direct legitimization of prevailing customary practices, but rather as a gradual and progressive regulatory measureaimed at protecting women’s legalandhuman rightsby restrictingsuchpractices. The study first investigates the nature of the Sunnah and the epistemological foundations of the Qur’ān–Sunnah relationship. It then examines the historical background of the principle “al‑Sunnah qāḍiyatun ʿalā al‑Kitāb,” formulated by Yaḥyā b. Abī Kathīr (d. 129/746). Methodologically, a comparative literature analysis was conducted through the classical exegetical tradition, beginning with the earliest tafsīr texts. In addition, the Prophet’s practical implementation and moral stance regarding the issue were evaluated through a textcentered content analysis. The findings reveal that the Prophet’s practical example functioned as the most fundamental interpretive element, narrowing the scope of the physical intervention mentioned in the verse and seeking to render it effectively inoperative. In this regard, the article argues that the issue of physical intervention in Qur’ān 4:34 cannot be reduced to a purely literal reading; rather, no reasonable conclusion can be reached without taking into account the normative authority, practical model, and moral vision of the Prophetic Sunnah. Byreassessing both classical and contemporary debates concerning the interpretation of Qur’ān 4:34 through the lens of the principle “al‑Sunnah qāḍiyatun ʿalā al‑Kitāb”, the study offers an original contribution to the tafsīr literature. Ultimately, it demonstrates, through a concrete case study, the determining role of the Prophetic model in the practical manifestation of Qur’ānic verses and in identifying the divine intent. In doing so, it provides a holistic perspective on methodological discussions concerning the relationship between the Qur’ān and the Sunnah.